Home/Sydney
Food and Beverage

Eating Your Way Through Newtown: A Local's Guide

6 SourcesUpdated December 12, 2025

TL;DR

Dive into the vibrant culinary heart of Newtown. This guide covers the suburb's must-try foods, from authentic deep-dish pizza at Yummy Box and world-champion gelato at Cow & The Moon to classic steaks at Macelleria, showcasing the best of Sydney's alternative food scene.

Introduction: The Heart of Sydney's Alternative Food Scene

Welcome to Newtown, the vibrant, bohemian heart of Sydney's Inner West. This is a neighbourhood that marches to the beat of its own drum, and its food scene is no exception. Known for its eclectic mix of vintage stores, street art, and a fiercely independent spirit, Newtown is also a culinary playground, offering a dense concentration of some of the city's most exciting and diverse eateries. From unique, handcrafted pizzas to world-champion gelato, this is a suburb that rewards the hungry explorer.

This guide will take you on a delicious journey through the must-try tastes of Newtown. Forget the tourist traps of the CBD; we're diving into the local favourites and hidden gems that make this neighbourhood a true food lover's paradise. Prepare to discover why Newtown is an essential destination for anyone looking to eat their way through the real Sydney.

Pizza Paradise: From Classic Neapolitan to Chicago Deep-Dish

Newtown is a serious destination for pizza lovers, offering both classic and unconventional styles executed at the highest level.

For a taste of tradition, head to Bella Brutta. Located conveniently near the University of Sydney, this spot is a local favourite that often requires a booking to snag a table. It's renowned for its perfectly blistered, wood-fired pizzas. The sausage and clam varieties come highly recommended, showcasing the kitchen's skill with high-quality ingredients and classic flavour combinations.

For something truly unique in the Sydney pizza landscape, you must visit Yummy Box. This unassuming spot is home to authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, a rarity in the city. The owner, who is Chinese, is deeply passionate about quality, making everything by hand, including the rich meat sauce for the poutine. The pizza itself is a marvel, with a thick, satisfying crust, a generous layer of cheese that creates an epic pull, and a hearty filling of beef, olives, and bell peppers. Be prepared to wait, as each pizza is handmade and takes about 30 minutes to bake. Don't miss their other standout dishes, like the Classic Poutine and the surprisingly delicious Chicken, Walnut & Orange Salad.

The Gelato Crawl: A Trio of Frozen Delights

On a warm Sydney day, there is no better place to be than Newtown, which boasts an incredible concentration of world-class gelato shops. It's a true paradise for anyone with a sweet tooth.

  • Cow & The Moon: This family-run gelateria isn't just a local favourite; it's a global champion. Having won the prestigious title of 'World's Best Gelato' in 2014, it's an essential stop for any dessert connoisseur. A scoop from here is a taste of award-winning perfection.

  • Gelato Messina: An undisputed icon of the Australian dessert scene, Gelato Messina has a cult following for a reason. With a vast menu of classic flavours and a rotating list of creative and often quirky weekly specials, there's always something new and exciting to try. It's a must-visit for the quintessential Sydney gelato experience.

  • Hakiki Newtown: For a completely different texture and taste, head to Hakiki. This shop specializes in traditional Turkish gelato, which is known for its unique, chewy consistency, almost like a cross between ice cream and taffy. It's a novel and delicious experience that offers a wonderful contrast to the classic Italian style.

Beyond the Sweets: A Carnivore's Haven

While pizza and gelato might be the stars, Newtown's culinary offerings are incredibly diverse. For meat lovers, a visit to Macelleria Newtown is a must. This establishment is both a butcher shop and a restaurant, guaranteeing the freshness and quality of its cuts.

The main event here is the steak. You can choose your cut directly from the display, and they will cook it for you to your liking. The T-bone steak comes highly recommended, cooked to a perfect medium-rare (五分熟) to ensure it's both tender and flavourful. Paired with a simple seasoning of sea salt and a side of mushroom sauce, it's a carnivore's dream. The ability to also purchase fresh meat to take home makes it a unique and popular spot for locals and visitors alike. For more information on dining in Sydney, you can visit the official tourism website.

Related Questions

What is Newtown known for?

Newtown is a vibrant and bohemian neighbourhood in Sydney's Inner West, known for its alternative culture, street art, and a diverse and high-quality food scene, especially its pizza and gelato.

Where can I find Chicago-style deep-dish pizza in Newtown?

Yummy Box on Missenden Road is a popular spot that serves authentic, handmade Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, a rarity in Sydney.

Which gelato shop in Newtown has won a world championship?

Cow & The Moon, a family-run gelateria in Newtown, won the 'World's Best Gelato' title in 2014.

What is special about the gelato at Hakiki Newtown?

Hakiki Newtown specializes in traditional Turkish gelato, which has a unique and distinctive chewy texture, different from Italian-style gelato.

Is there a good place for traditional wood-fired pizza in Newtown?

Yes, Bella Brutta, located near the University of Sydney, is a highly recommended restaurant for classic wood-fired pizzas, with the clam and sausage pizzas being popular choices.

Where can I get a good steak in Newtown?

Macelleria Newtown is both a butcher and a restaurant, where you can choose a fresh cut of meat, such as a T-bone steak, and have it cooked for you.

What are some other must-try gelato shops in Newtown besides Cow & The Moon?

Newtown is also home to a branch of the iconic Gelato Messina, famous for its creative flavours, and Hakiki, which serves chewy Turkish-style gelato.

Are there any recommended non-pizza dishes at Yummy Box?

Yes, besides their deep-dish pizza, the Classic Poutine with house-made meat sauce and the Chicken, Walnut & Orange Salad are also highly praised.

How long does the deep-dish pizza at Yummy Box take to cook?

Because it is handmade to order, the Chicago deep-dish pizza at Yummy Box takes approximately 30 minutes to bake.

What is the recommended cooking level for a steak at Macelleria?

A medium-rare cook (五分熟) is recommended for the T-bone steak at Macelleria to ensure it is tender and flavourful.

Related Articles

Sources

[1]

❤️‍🔥终于吃到了悉尼newtown 深底披萨🍕

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/68a85e...

[2]

悉尼旅游必吃🍦Gelato冰淇淋!必吃榜

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/68e723...

[3]

悉尼坠好吃的🍕

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/68c65d...

[4]

❤️‍🔥终于吃到了悉尼newtown 深底披萨🍕

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/68a85e...

[5]

悉尼旅游必吃🍦Gelato冰淇淋!必吃榜

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/68e723...

[6]

🇦🇺悉尼美食推荐-上篇

https://www.xiaohongshu.com/explore/689221...

Daisy Club - Influencer-Fueled Lifestyle and Travel Publisher

Daisy Club is an ambassador-powered lifestyle and travel publication that turns real stays and nights out into global discovery content. Our brands partner with handpicked micro-influencers—our "ambassadors"—to bring their experiences to life. Ambassadors stay at hotels, dine at restaurants, explore bars and try unique activities, then share authentic content on the social platforms where their audiences already live. We turn this source content into rich, editorial-style articles that make these experiences discoverable to a global audience. From hidden rooftop bars to design-driven hotels and must-try food spots, starting with the top travel cities across Asia Pacific, Daisy Club is building the freshest living guide to where to stay, eat and play around the world.

© 2025 Daisy Club. All rights reserved.